News

Fun Facts of the 34th Vis Moot Case: What’s Hiding Beneath the Surface?

Ogün Erşan Aydınlı 8 min read

Ocean-law pioneers, famous explorers, literary references, and a few coincidences that might not be coincidences at all.

The 34th Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot takes us thousands of metres below the ocean’s surface. At the centre of the dispute between Blue Ocean Services plc and Nautilus Engineering Ltd is a deep-sea mining vehicle, a complicated contractual relationship, and some rather interesting questions about international arbitration and the CISG.

But beyond the legal arguments, there’s another story to discover.

Look closely at the names, addresses, dates, and even the Zoom invitations, and you’ll find references to real scientists, pioneers of the law of the sea, literary characters, and popular culture.

Here are some of our favourite discoveries.

1. A Presiding Arbitrator with an Ocean-Law Legacy

Prof. Elisabeth M. Borgese sounds like a perfectly ordinary name for an arbitrator. Until you meet Elisabeth Mann Borgese.

Born on 24 April 1918, Elisabeth Mann Borgese was a remarkable figure in the development of modern ocean governance. Known as “The Mother of the Oceans,” she founded the International Ocean Institute in Malta in 1972 and dedicated much of her life to promoting international cooperation in the management of ocean resources.

And now, a fictional arbitrator bearing a name remarkably close to hers is presiding over a dispute involving deep-sea mining.

Quite an appropriate appointment.

2. Two Arbitrators, Two Reassembled Names

The other members of the arbitral tribunal are Dr. Spencer F. Prado and Mr. Arvid Baird.

Their names appear to combine two real historical figures.

Arvid Pardo was Malta’s first Permanent Representative to the United Nations. In 1967, he delivered a landmark address advocating the treatment of the seabed beyond national jurisdiction and its resources as the common heritage of mankind.

Spencer F. Baird, meanwhile, was an American naturalist, the first United States Commissioner of Fish and Fisheries, and the second Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution.

Put Spencer and Arvid together, rearrange Pardo and Baird, and the tribunal suddenly starts looking like a gathering of maritime history.

3. Auguste Piccard: From the Stratosphere to the Seabed

Auguste Piccard, CEO of Blue Ocean Services, shares his name with the Swiss physicist and explorer whose achievements extended to both extremes of the planet.

The real Auguste Piccard was a pioneer of stratospheric balloon flights and the inventor of the bathyscaphe, a vessel designed to explore the deep ocean.

But his influence extends beyond science.

Hergé, the creator of The Adventures of Tintin, famously drew inspiration from Piccard when creating Professor Calculus. The scientist was so tall that Hergé reportedly had to imagine a smaller version of him to fit the comic panels.

There’s also a frequently repeated connection between the Piccard family and the name of Captain Jean-Luc Picard from Star Trek, although the precise origin of that name is less firmly established.

From Tintin to the seabed, Piccard has certainly travelled far.

4. Alfred Wegener and Ellen Scripps: Scientists on Opposite Sides

The scientific references don’t stop with Piccard.

Alfred Wegener, Blue Ocean’s Chief Technical Officer, shares his name with the German scientist who proposed the theory of continental drift. A fitting choice for someone responsible for the technical performance of an ocean-floor mining vehicle.

On the opposing side, we have Dr. Ellen B. Scripps, CEO of Nautilus Engineering.

Her name recalls Ellen Browning Scripps, the American journalist and philanthropist whose contributions helped establish the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, California.

Two names deeply connected to the study of our planet, now involved in a dispute about what happens beneath its oceans.

5. Jules Verne Is Everywhere

This might be the most obvious literary reference in the case, but it deserves attention.

Nautilus Engineering. Nemo Holdings. Jules Verne Avenue 20.

The connection leads straight to Jules Verne’s Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Seas, featuring Captain Nemo and his submarine, the Nautilus.

And the address is particularly interesting.

Nautilus Engineering is located at Jules Verne Avenue 20.

Why 20?

It could simply be a reference to the book’s title. But Article 20 of the original Sales Agreement also contains the arbitration clause central to the dispute.

Coincidence? Possibly. A rather clever choice of address? Definitely.

There’s another detail worth mentioning: nemo means “no one” in Latin.

Nemo Holdings plays an important role in the commercial background of the dispute, yet it is not itself a party to the arbitration.

Literally, no one at the table.

And beyond fiction, there’s Point Nemo, the location in the Pacific Ocean farthest from any landmass, also named after Verne’s famous captain.

6. An Unexpected Appearance by Wes Anderson

Turn to the minutes of the meeting held on 7 February 2024.

The person taking notes is Steve Zissou.

If that name sounds familiar, you’ve probably watched Wes Anderson’s The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou.

In the film, Steve Zissou is an eccentric oceanographer and explorer, portrayed by Bill Murray and inspired in part by Jacques-Yves Cousteau.

In the Vis Moot file, he’s simply the personal assistant taking meeting minutes.

A rather unexpected career change.

7. The Man Who Found the Titanic

Another familiar name appears in those meeting minutes.

R. Ballard, the Chief Financial Officer of Nautilus Engineering, recalls Robert Ballard, the American oceanographer best known for co-leading the expedition that discovered the wreck of the Titanic in 1985.

So, in a single meeting, we have characters whose names evoke continental drift, deep-sea exploration, oceanographic research, and one of history’s most famous shipwrecks.

Not a bad guest list.

8. Even the Addresses Have a Story

The case’s fictional geography is full of references.

Jacques-Yves Cousteau Avenue 33 is the address of the presiding arbitrator, Prof. Borgese.

Jacques-Yves Cousteau was the French naval officer, oceanographer, filmmaker, and explorer whose work brought the underwater world into millions of homes.

Then there’s Bathybius Drive 1886, the address of Blue Ocean Services.

The name recalls Bathybius haeckelii, a supposed primordial organism described by Thomas Henry Huxley in 1868 from deep-sea mud samples. It was later shown not to be a living organism.

The number 1886 is also an intriguing detail: it contains the same digits as 1868, the year associated with Huxley’s description, in a different order.

Whether intentional or not, it’s a particularly fitting reference for a case centred on the deep ocean.

9. A Birthday Call Nobody Asked For

Now for one of the smaller details.

According to the problem, Dr. Scripps called Auguste Piccard on 23 January 2024 to explain Nautilus Engineering’s financial difficulties.

According to Piccard’s witness statement, he was born on 23 January 1970.

Yes, the call took place on his 54th birthday.

Imagine receiving a call on your birthday only to discover that your USD 25 million advance payment may be at risk.

Happy birthday, Mr. Piccard.

10. Gemini, Gemini… and Two Contracts?

Let’s venture briefly outside legal analysis.

According to the birth dates provided in the case:

  • Auguste Piccard: 23 January 1970 — Aquarius.
  • Alfred Wegener: 9 June 1961 — Gemini.
  • Dr. Ellen B. Scripps: 7 June 1967 — Gemini.

Notice anything?

Wegener and Scripps, two important figures on opposite sides of the dispute, are both Geminis.

And what is one of the central legal questions in the case?

One contract or two?

Gemini is, of course, represented by the twins.

We’re not suggesting that astrology has suddenly become a source of international commercial law. But the symbolism is amusingly appropriate.

11. The Most Meaningful Zoom Passcode of the Year

Even the procedural correspondence contains an Easter egg.

In the Zoom invitations issued by the ICDR, the meeting passcode is:

100 Years

The American Arbitration Association (AAA) was founded in 1926 and celebrates its centenary in 2026.

The International Centre for Dispute Resolution (ICDR), the AAA’s international division, administers the arbitration in this year’s Vis Moot.

One hundred years of arbitration history, neatly tucked into a Zoom invitation.

12. Nautilus Isn’t Entirely Fictional

Finally, there is a real-world connection to the subject matter itself.

A company called Nautilus Minerals pursued commercial deep-sea mining, including the Solwara 1 project near Papua New Guinea. The company later encountered serious financial difficulties and entered insolvency proceedings.

The fictional Nautilus Engineering also operates in the deep-sea mining sector and faces a financial crisis.

There is no need to assume that one story was directly based on the other. Still, the parallel is difficult to miss.

One Last Thing: The Characters as MBTI Types

We couldn’t resist.

This is entirely speculative, entirely unscientific, and absolutely not part of the legal analysis. But if the characters had personality types, our guesses would be:

Character Our MBTI Guess
Auguste Piccard ENFJ
Alfred Wegener INFP
Dr. Ellen B. Scripps ENTP
Joseph Langweiler ISTJ
Julia Clara Fasttrack ENTJ
Prof. Elisabeth M. Borgese INFJ

Feel free to disagree. Particularly if you’re representing the other side.


There’s More to a Moot Problem Than Meets the Eye

The 34th Vis Moot problem invites us to examine difficult questions about contractual obligations, arbitral jurisdiction, and the international sale of goods.

But its fictional world also pays apparent tribute to the people, discoveries, and stories that shaped our understanding of the oceans.

Some references are unmistakable. Others are coincidences, plausible interpretations, or simply entertaining theories.

That’s part of the fun.

The next time you read the problem, pay attention to the details. You might discover something that has nothing to do with your memorandum — but makes the case considerably more interesting.

An informal collection of observations by Vis Moot Atılım. These interpretations are offered for entertainment and are not official explanations of the problem or statements of the problem author’s intentions.